A Question for the Engineering Team (ie, for the "ET" people, not the "IT" people for a change).
I have a query on the stated MAN 9L 58/64 engine weight. On a handout that was distributed by the chief engineer's department, and was also posted on the Cunard 'QE2' website information pages, the stated weight for each main engine was "about 120 tons".
Having been around marine engines for a little while, the figure never did quite 'feel' right, so last night I went on to the MAN website for the 9L58/64 engine and found the actual engine weight is 208 tons 'without the flywheel'. The bed plate is an additional 50 tons, so, adding in the 2 ton flywheel, then the generator weight of approx 70 tons, the total weight of each diesel electric genset as installed on QE2 is around 330 tons.
I then checked my copy of "The QE2 Refit", REBIRTH OF A QUEEN", produced by Marine Propulsion International in May 1987, in association with Lloyd-Werft, and MAN B&W. This publication gives the engine weights of 220 tons each, generators are 70 tons each, and the 17 metre long bedplates that everything sits on are 50 tons each
Carol Thatcher's book on page 179 refers to the "220 tonne engines". I am sure this lady did her research thoroughly.
How did the Cunard blurb get it so wrong for so long? Did nobody actually read it or query it?
For the technophobes, here is a bit of the info I found on the engine manufacturers website:
Cylinder liner weight 1178 kg each
Cylinder head weight 2200 kg ea.
Connecting rod weight 962 kg ea.
Fuel injection pump for ONE cylinder 154 kg
Gudgeon pin weight 163 kg ea.
Engine length (exc generator) 12.6 metres
Engine height 5.14 metres
Coolant vol to fill engine 1240 litres
Lube Oil - minimum 295 litres.
For Myles, to answer your question above about how much new machinery was installed, this gives the total weight of the 9 new gensets only as approx 2,970 tons. But, the total weight of ALL the new machinery installed was 4,500 tons, being new propulsion motors, props & propeller shafts, shaft bearings, 2 new oil-fired boilers, 9 new exhaust gas boilers, all the pumps, systems, coolers, condensors, evaporators, separators and whatever else added up to another 1,500 tons.
Rich, thanks for the TCR/ECR info. Just looking on page 36 of Carol Thatcher's book it shows them both. I should look before I ask, but then, it is much more sociable to ask is it not?
And Gav, thanks for the kind words. You have probably realised that I just love getting into the nuts and bolts of things. When my son was posted to the QE2 in Jan 2007 I was very happy that he got the chance to sail on her. I didn't realise that he was going to arrange for his parents to sail on her as well. Some engineers in the wardy probably thought I asked too many questions about 'the job', but that interested me as much as the people who operated the ship. QE2 felt so "right" to be on that I came off her, have spent 20 months revalidating my tickets, and am now back at sea again myself.
Cheers
Skilly